Write what you are looking for and press enter to begin your search!

Logo
live-news-icon

Live News

The Animators Of Arcane League Of Legends Would Love To Adapt This Classic Manga: In an intense match, the Lone Wolves came out victorious. Read all about the big night here // Call Of Duty Black Ops 6: How To Access The Multiplayer Beta & When: In an intense match, the Lone Wolves came out victorious. Read all about the big night here // Paraside: Duality Unbound is a Dual Realm Strategy RPG Scheduled for 2025: In an intense match, the Lone Wolves came out victorious. Read all about the big night here
post-16 post-13

Open World Sandbox Games Like RDR2 Are Limited; Here’s Why

Like most people, I loved Red Dead Redemption 2. It’s the best that Rockstar has offered in terms of storytelling, characters, and dialogue. However, I have a hard time classifying it as my favourite Rockstar game and that’s mainly because the overall gameplay just isn’t all that great.

After more than an entire decade of playing the Grand Theft Autos and also the first Red Dead Redemption, I couldn’t help but think that no one else could make open world sandbox games as fun as Rockstar did. A lot of developers tried but they never seem to have reached the same level of polish and creativity.

I don’t blame them. Making fun and interesting sandbox games is anything but simple, and I believe Rockstar is reaching their limits too.

When Enough Is Enough

I take RDR2 as the yardstick here because its open world is at worst still one of the best in the industry. From the muddy soils of Valentine to the snow-capped mountains in the Grizzlies, everything feels detailed and alive. Just woke up at camp and noticed that you buy some more ammo? Well, you might just get robbed on your way to town.

rdr2_fishing

Being the critically-acclaimed giant that they are, there’s no doubt that Rockstar knew about the whole “wide as an ocean, deep as a puddle” criticism that a lot of open world games were getting. And it’s obvious they did their very best to make sure RDR2 would be spared from such scathing words. But alas, the open world has probably reached its limits. Its own invisible walls.

About 30% through the game, I had already come across similar “random” encounters at least twice. I’d fall asleep more than a handful of times while tapping X to get to my destination. And when I do get to my destination, I realise there wasn’t much fun to be had anyway. It was just another “talk to mission giver, ride with mission giver to location, kill enemies at location” session.

Forgoing linearity for the sake of “freedom” is (to me) the main cause of this stagnation in game design. A purpose has to be given to a big world because without one, it would be too obvious that a big world was never a necessity. If the purpose is to merely give a sense of freedom and expansiveness, then the most important question in gaming has to be asked yet again: Do those things make the game fun?

Not Your First Open World Rodeo

There’s no need to look back at last year to understand this conundrum. Everyone’s got bullet points of what they didn’t like about Bioware’s looter-shooter Anthem and variations of “beautiful but ultimately unremarkable open world” is almost always one of the points. The developers hyped up the idea of having your own Iron Man suit and having the freedom to fly anywhere you want. They forgot to add that it was only for anywhere devoid of interesting content.

anthem-hands-on-2711-1920x1080.jpg

And it’s not just games everyone likes to crap on that has this problem. Of course, RDR2 was a good enough example of this but for the sake of showing how it isn’t uncommon, take a look at other past releases that boasted their open worlds. Final Fantasy XV, GOTY material to many, had invisible walls and pretty much on-rails driving mechanics (comfy though, according to many people).

Dragon Age Inquisition, again a popular choice for GOTY, had a single-player MMORPG design which made its huge and beautiful areas feel like chores to travel through.

What Should Be Done?

So at this point, it’s only appropriate that I provide some sort of counter-idea to open world games and fortunately for me, there’s been a bunch of very good linear or non-sandbox games which were released quite recently.

Look at the Resident Evil 2 remake. Look at its design. Look at how it ignores the idea of “bigger worlds, hundreds of hours of gameplay” and just stands there atop its pyramid stack of 10/10 scores.

re2_remake_licket

Heck, the game literally challenges you to replay it and see if you can beat it under 3 hours and so far I’ve seen nobody complain about that. One of us here even thinks it’s the gold standard for video game replayability.

But it has to be said that RE2 is a horror game and almost all great horror games are linear by design to emphasise the lack of freedom and thus the player’s ability to escape whatever scares them.

To that, I bring up Devil May Cry 5.

601150_20190311200143_1.png

Fast-paced hack and slash combat with deep mechanics? Hell yeah. Colourful visuals with high-resolution details and particle effects? The RE Engine got you covered. Big open world for you to express your freedom and desire to run around aimlessly? No thanks!

DMC5 sticks to its regular 20-mission structure and excels at pacing your enjoyment. There are puzzles from time to time to make you think for a bit but 90% of the time you’re just seconds away from kicking more demons ass. No 10-minute drive to your next destination. No exposition dialogue to make it feel as if the travelling is necessary. Just you having fun with a game that doesn’t take itself too seriously.

The truth of this matter has always been spouted endlessly in cliche lines used by businessmen and writing editors: quality, not quantity.

Perhaps it’s time for developers to rethink about their efforts in creating gigantic worlds and trying to fill them with interesting and fun interactions. Maybe create interesting and fun scenarios then try filling a world with them. A world of just traversing from one fun setpiece to another.

Related News

post-07
The Epic Games Store Will Continue Giving Away Free Games In 2020

When the Epic Games Store (EGS) first came out, almost nobody anything had anything positive to say about it. Feature-wise, it was embarrassingly barr...

post-07
Y The Last Man TV Series Gets Epic First Trailer

FX’s highly-anticipated TV series adaptation of Brian K. Vaughan and Pia Guerra’s Y The Last Man has finally received an official premie...

post-07
Guardians Of The Galaxy's PC Requirements Include 150GB Of Disk Space

Square Enix and Eidos Montreal's upcoming action-adventure title Marvel's Guardians of the Galaxy will be out later this month, with its PC specs avai...

Write a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Tournament Tool Kit

Kakuchopurei Community

Popular Posts

post-17
Tekken 8 Tier List For July 2024 According To One Of The Best Players In The World
post-17
EVO 2024: Full Schedule & Results
post-17
Last Epoch Harbingers Of Ruin 1.1 Patch Is Live Now
post-17
Zenless Zone Zero: Best Protips To Keep Yourself Alive In New Eridu & The Hollow
post-17
FV Major 2024: What You Need To Know About Malaysia’s Biggest Fighting Game Tournament
post-17
[Updated] Honor of Kings Invitational Season 2: Full Schedule & Results
post-17
The 10 Best Soulslike Games Not Made By FromSoftware
post-17
Elden Ring: Shadow Of The Erdtree DLC Guide – Best Weapons, Spells, & Ashes Of War Early On
post-17
Honkai Star Rail 2.3 Update: Firefly Guide & Best Builds
post-17
Shin Megami Tensei V Endings & New Game Plus Guide: How To Get All Of Them
post-17
Shin Megami Tensei V: Vengeance – How To Find Nahobeeho
post-17
Fatal Fury: City of the Wolves – What You Need To Know About The Upcoming 2025 Fighting Game From SNK
post-17
XDefiant: Best Loadouts To Melt Your Enemies
post-17
XDefiant: The Best Guns To Dominate Pubs
post-17
Diablo 4 Season 4: The Best Builds Per Class To Get To Level 100 Fast!
post-17
Diablo 4 Season 4: Tempering & Masterworks Guide
post-17
Hades 2 Guide: All Incantations And Effects At Hecate’s Cauldron
post-17
Hades 2: All Boons List & The Best Ones
post-17
Eiyuden Chronicle: Hundred Heroes – 11 Tips To Get Ahead In This JRPG
post-17
Eiyuden Chronicle: Hundred Heroes Review – Rally Forth
post-17
Final Fantasy VII Rebirth Queen’s Blood Guide: The Best Cards & Decks
post-17
Introducing The Kakuchopurei YouTube Membership Program!
post-17
Palworld: All The Guides You Need For 2024’s Surprise Survival Game Hit
post-17
Main Game: How To Watch Malaysia’s Best Video Game Show Created By Kakuchopurei & RTM
post-17
Marvel’s What If…? Crew Explains Why They Went 3D Over 2D & A Scrapped Episode That Was Too Close To GOTG 3
post-17
Hawkeye Episode 6 Finale Easter Eggs & Breakdown
post-17
We Talk To Hayden Christensen About Star Wars, Sequels, & Prequels
post-17
Sea Of Stars Might Get DLC Post-Launch
post-17
The Book Of Boba Fett Episode 7 Breakdown & Easter Eggs Explained