Silver Pines Review: Twin Peaks & Silent Hill’s 2D Lovechild Done Right?

Platform(s): PC (version reviewed), Xbox Series, PS5
Genre: 2D, Search Action, Metroidvania, Horror

It’s not every day you come across a pure 2D search action adventure title that really nails the survival horror vibe and feel. Yes, past Resident Evil titles (and the remakes) handle that in a 3D space while still delivering chills and scares, but I do feel that the 2D plane is solely relegated to the “action” part of the subgenre.

Turns out with the right animation and lighting technique, along with some good old-fashioned roundabout level design, you can make a chilling and mysterious horror adventure title gel well with a metroidvania. That is indie team Wych Elm’s new title Silver Pines, and it’s a noteworthy addition to this year’s ever-abundant giant-map-exploration-action style of games.

“Black as midnight on a moonless night”

In Silver Pines, you play as troubled private eye Red Walker as you are tasked with finding a missing musician whose last known location is the title town. You explore the 2D realm of interconnecting abandoned townships and shops, ruined apartments, underground tunnels and sewers, backwoods, and a ton more dread-inducing places. There’s little to no one present in Silver Pines due to the oncoming storm, but as you play through the first 30 minutes, you find out that there’s a lot more to worry about than mother nature. And its central mystery on the town and even your own troubles from the past start surfacing and literally assaulting you as you come close to solving the game’s many survival horror-coded puzzles. These range from finding the right tool to open barricades and doors, to scouring for ammo while conserving what you have left as you dodge horrors and the undead(?) left and right. And sometimes from above or even below.

Every odd locale in the game will have its own puzzles and clues scattered within the vicinity; here’s where you take your time doing detective work and piecing solutions to what’s blocking progression. Strange statues with missing pieces, newspaper clippings on walls – it’s what you expect from a survival horror-slash-point-and-click adventure game but it’s done so with lovely animation, aesthetics, and a muted backdrop that fits the alluring mystery surrounding the town. Next to Tenebris Somnia, there isn’t another survival horror game as stylish and as hauntingly gorgeous as Silver Pines.

Combat is tense and challenging, with limited resources and purposefully-gimped controls making you think twice before you unload your gun on smaller enemies. Sometimes it’s better to just run, and thankfully you have options for that. Boss battles in specially-telegraphed rooms will at least have the courtesy to give you some ammo before you head in, but it’s definitely Silver Pines’ most glaring issue. They take a while to kill, and will make you really use even your cumbersome melee options as a last resort. Overall, it’s the type of gameplay tell that you need to be wary of your surroundings and your supplies since you set foot in your first dark-and-foreboding alleyway in Silver Pines.

Saving your game is also scarce; you need to find coins in-game to use a payphone that lets you keep progress, though you cannot spam it and need to rely on skill and survival notions to get to the next major area with a payphone. It’s tense, but thankfully not too draggy and completely punishing with its runbacks. But like I said; the boss battles do skew towards the frustrating side at times to the point that you’re tempted to tone down the difficulty.

“There was a fish in the percolator…”

While a bit rough in some places, you cannot deny the artistry and love behind this horror metroidvania experience. If you have huge love of all things Silent Hill and Twin Peaks, or just video game survival horror in general, you do owe it to yourself to enthrall yourself in this indie wonder.

Final Score: 80/100

Review copy provided by publisher. 

 

Leave a Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *